Levine played the role of Lucy van Pelt in the 1999 revival of the Broadway play You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown. She has also appeared on Broadway in Jake's Women, The Last Night of Ballyhoo, and Wrong Mountain. She is the host of the popular iTunes podcast, Little Known Facts with Ilana Levine. She is married to actor Dominic Fumusa; they have two children: Georgia and Caleb. Her husband converted to Judaism.