Amurri married former Major League Soccer player and current NBC Sports broadcaster Kyle Martino on October 29, 2011. They have two children, a daughter, Marlowe Mae, (born August 2014) and a son, Major James, (born October 2016). In August 2015, Amurri Martino revealed they had a miscarriage at nine weeks. Amurri Martino is a longtime resident of Pound Ridge, New York.